What Does a Tree Eat? Part Two

What Does a Tree Eat? Part Two

I reported in my previous post that seventh graders, in three science classes, believed that a tree grows by eating dirt. Historically, that is exactly the belief held up to the Middle Ages.

In 1634 the Belgian Jean Baptist van Helmont performed what may be the first experiment on plant growth. He too hypothesized that a plant grows by somehow absorbing dirt.

To test his theory he devised the following experiment. In an earthen pot containing 200 pounds of soil that had been dried in an oven, he planted a five-pound willow tree shoot. He watered the plant with rainwater and let it grow, watering as necessary.
Willow Tree
After the tree had grown for five years, he re-weighed the tree and found that it had grown to 169 pounds. He again dried the soil, weighed it, and found that it still weighed 200 pounds. He concluded that the tree grew by drinking water and not by eating dirt.

In the third and last post in this series I will explain that “eats dirt” may be what science education researcher Dr. Andrea diSessa calls a phenomenological primitive (p-prim). Children, just by living in the physical world, develop their own set of p-prims that may or may not affect their ability to learn school science. The AIMS Center for Math and Science Education is assembling a research team to explore how to help students identify their p-prims. Once identified, students can compare their p-prims with established science and make the necessary adjustments.

Reference
Hershey, David R. (1991) Digging Deeper into Helmont’s Famous Willow Tree Experiment. The American Biology Teacher.

How I See the Change at AIMS Affecting the Graduate Math & Science Education Program at FPU. – Part Two

How I See the Change at AIMS Affecting the Graduate Math & Science Education Program at FPU. – Part Two

Since AIMS grew out of efforts by FPU faculty in the 1980s the two entities have been closely tied together. This will remain the same in the future, in fact even more closely linked than ever before. All the professors in GMSFPU will also be spending time at the Center. And with the focus of…

What Unit is the Child Counting?-Perceptual and Figural Unit Items

What Unit is the Child Counting?-Perceptual and Figural Unit Items

In my last blog I talked about some of Dr. Leslie Steffe’s research and how he observed fractional understanding develop in children through counting and their understanding of number. He has articulated the following five stages of counting types in his book Children’s Counting Types: These stages are important in a child’s ability to work…

Professional Development in an Education World of Accountability

Professional Development in an Education World of Accountability

The AIMS Center for Math and Science Education is prepared to help. We are available to collaborate and build an effective Professional Development Plan for your school or district. We know that educators benefit from good sustained professional development and in today’s high stakes era of standards and student achievement it is usually focused on…

What Does a Tree Eat?

What Does a Tree Eat?

One of the failings that science education researchers generally agree on is that our science instruction does not begin with an attempt to find out what students know, and therefore what they really believe about a science topic, before we teach it. Photosynthesis, the process used by plants to convert light energy into chemical energy…

Learning What Steffe’s Research Found Supports Fractional Knowledge

Learning What Steffe’s Research Found Supports Fractional Knowledge

I have always been passionate about how children learn and equipping teachers with the tools that would empower them to be more effective teachers. So, when the opportunity to work at The AIMS Center for Math and Science Education at Fresno Pacific University became available, I enthusiastically applied. As a research associate at The AIMS…

How I See the Change at AIMS Affecting the Graduate Math & Science Education Program at FPU. – Part One

How I See the Change at AIMS Affecting the Graduate Math & Science Education Program at FPU. – Part One

Hello dear readers. I may be a new voice on this blog to those of you who read it regularly so perhaps a brief introduction is in order. I see myself as a High School Math teacher who has gotten a wonderful opportunity to play in a big sandbox. I taught math to students from…

AIMS Math and Science Professional Development

AIMS Math and Science Professional Development

I am on my way to Michigan to facilitate professional development in mathematics. I will share a full day of hands-on activities that can easily be supplemented in to a teacher’s math curriculum. Why did this small school district choose AIMS to facilitate their professional development? They were aware that AIMS could do the following…

What the Science Education Research Says!

What the Science Education Research Says!

Long before the Next Generation Science Standards were all the buzz I downloaded from the National Research Council (NRC) web site a free copy of the book, Taking Science to School – Learning and Teaching Science in Grades K-8, ©2007. I found the messages contained in the document’s Executive Summary compelling because they closely matched…

What the Internet is Doing to Our Brains

What the Internet is Doing to Our Brains

Nicholas Carr, a writer whose interest is in technology and culture, published an article in a 2008 issue of The Atlantic Monthly with the provocative title, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” In the article he talks about what he believes the Internet is doing to our brains. He describes what he says he feels is…